Erling Haaland vs Lionel Messi

Born 13 years apart and never on the same pitch, they finished first and second for the 2023 Ballon d'Or and level on points for FIFA's The Best, which Messi won on the votes of national-team captains.

By the Oddsivio teamLast reviewed Stats updated

Erling Haaland
Erling Haaland

Manchester CityManchester CityStriker · 26 yrs

4,968 min · 61 matchesChange

Last season · club and country together · official matches

Lionel Messi
Lionel Messi

Inter MiamiInter MiamiStriker · 39 yrs

3,981 min · 46 matchesChange

Who does what?

Lionel Messi created more chances, had more assists and completed a higher share of passes last season, and they were level on goals.

Worth knowing: Erling Haaland had 4,968 minutes last season, Lionel Messi 3,981.

What separates them

3 of 4 pass both our tests: a big enough gap, and sure enough to hold.

  • Haaland
  • Messi
  • Typical forwardsThe shaded band is the middle half of forwards (25th to 75th percentile) over the last two years: where typical forwards sit.
  1. Goals per 90
    Level
    1.0357 goals
    1.0245 goals

    Too small a gap against typical forwards to name a leader.

  2. Chances created per 90
    Messi led
    0.844 chances
    3.2140 chances

    About 4.0 times as many chances created: about 71 more over 30 full matches.

    Held up next season: about 9 in 10We looked back at 81,063 past pairs of forwards with a chances created gap this size across 9 past seasons: about 9 in 10 still had the same leader the following season. It rates this one gap, not the whole verdict.

  3. Assists per 90
    Messi led
    0.2011 assists
    0.4118 assists

    About 6 more assists over 30 full matches for Messi than Haaland.

    Held up next season: about 7 in 10The share of past pairs from the same group with a gap this size whose leader still led the following season. It rates this one gap, not the whole verdict.

  4. Pass completion share of passes completed
    Messi led
    67%
    82%

    Pass completion depends a lot on role and team.

    Held up next season: about 9 in 10The share of past pairs from the same group with a gap this size whose leader still led the following season. It rates this one gap, not the whole verdict.

Per 90 = per 90 minutes played, so different minutes compare fairly.

Does it hold up?

  • Without penalties

    Too close to call (52 goals to 44).

How they play · volume, not a lead

Lionel Messi tried far more take-ons (5.9 vs 0.9 per 90) and won far more duels (5.7 vs 3.5 per 90) last season.

Why this comparison

Their argument is about 2023, not about any game. That year's Ballon d'Or covered the 2022–23 season, which held both Haaland's first year at Manchester City, with 52 goals in 53 games and a treble completed by the club's first Champions League, and the World Cup in Qatar, which Messi won with Argentina, named the tournament's best player. Messi won in Paris, with 462 points to Haaland's 357. FIFA's The Best, which left out the World Cup, was announced in January 2024 with the two level on 48 points, and under FIFA's rules the tie went to the votes of national-team captains: 107 of them had put Messi first and 64 Haaland. Messi, voting as Argentina's captain, had put Haaland first.

Pep Guardiola coached both, Messi at Barcelona from 2008 to 2012 and Haaland at City from 2022 until he left in May 2026, and has been asked to compare them since. "Nothing is comparable with Leo," he said in October 2022, two months into Haaland's first season, and ten days before the 2023 Ballon d'Or was announced he said, as he always had, that it should have two sections, one for Messi and one for the others; both deserved it, he added, but he wanted Haaland to win, because City had won the treble on his 52 goals.

Every number · last season
HaalandStatMessi
4,968
Minutes
3,981
61
Matches
46
76.9Star · 40 club games · as of 2026-11-22
Current squad importance
87.5Star · 40 club games · as of 2026-11-22
1.0357 in total
goals per 90
1.0245 in total
0.2011 in total
assists per 90
0.4118 in total
0.844 in total
chances created per 90
3.2140 in total
3.3180 in total
shots per 90
3.5154 in total
0.947 in total
take-ons tried per 90
5.9263 in total
0.318 in total
tackles per 90
0.733 in total
0.17 in total
interceptions per 90
0.16 in total
3.5195 in total
duels won per 90
5.7254 in total
67%
pass completion
82%

Goals and assists are counted from match events; the other counts come from the provider's detailed match stats. Squad importance describes the current club role over its recent club-game window; it is independent of the comparison window.

Have they played each other?

Never. By 10 November 2026 they had not played in the same game, for or against each other. Norway and Argentina have met twice, both times in friendlies in Oslo, in 1986 and in August 2007, when Messi played in a 2–1 defeat and Haaland was seven. The first near misses came in the Champions League. Messi played in both of Barcelona's group games against Borussia Dortmund in the autumn of 2019; on the night of the first, 17 September, Haaland scored a hat-trick on his Champions League debut for Salzburg, and Dortmund announced his signing on 29 December, a month after the second. In September 2021 Messi scored his first goal for Paris Saint-Germain against Manchester City while Haaland was still at Dortmund, and in 2022–23, with Messi at PSG and Haaland at City, the two clubs were never drawn together. At the 2025 Club World Cup both went out in the last 16, Inter Miami to PSG on 29 June 2025 and City to Al Hilal a day later. At the 2026 World Cup Norway and Argentina were in the same half of the draw: had Norway beaten England in their quarter-final in Miami on 11 July, they would have played Argentina, who beat Switzerland the same day, in the semi-final in Atlanta, but England won 2–1 after extra time. Messi played his last game for Argentina on 6 October 2026, so any meeting now would have to be between Manchester City and Inter Miami, and none had been announced by 10 November 2026.

Looking up their matches…

What the numbers don't show

The card's last season is a different stretch of the calendar for each of them. Haaland's is Manchester City's 2025–26 season, which ended with the FA Cup, the League Cup and second place in the Premier League, with Norway's competitive games up to the World Cup quarter-final: 61 games and 4,968 minutes. Messi's is Inter Miami's 2025 season, from February to MLS Cup in December, with Argentina's competitive games from September 2025 to the World Cup final: 46 games and 3,981 minutes. The card does not adjust for the strength of a league, and most of Messi's minutes came in MLS, most of Haaland's in the Premier League and the Champions League.

They do different jobs inside those minutes. Haaland is a centre-forward who touches the ball less than almost anyone: Opta counted 24.2 touches per 90 minutes for him in the first seven Premier League games of 2025–26, the third-lowest in the league among players with 300 minutes or more, and 69.6% of them came under high pressure. In the card's last-season figures on 10 November 2026, Messi created four times as many chances per 90 minutes and tried more than six times as many take-ons. Five of Haaland's 57 goals in that window came from the penalty spot and one of Messi's 45, and the card's row without penalties sets them aside.

Messi's assists need a note. Our match feed credits only the last pass before a goal, and it has missed some of his at Inter Miami: it gives him 12 in their 2025 MLS season, play-offs included, where MLS, which also credits the pass before the last when it leads directly to a goal, counts 28. His assist count on the card is a floor, not a full count.

Estimated value

Erling Haaland's Oddsivio estimated value is higher: €186m (#5 of 11,790 players valued) to Lionel Messi's €11m (#1,419 of 11,790 players valued). Haaland's estimate rose 9% since season start; Messi's estimate dipped 31% this season.Oddsivio estimated value — a model estimate from recent performance data, not betting advice.

Erling Haaland

Oddsivio estimated value

Higher

€186m

+9% since season start

#5 of 11,790 players valued#2 of 522 in the Premier League

Lionel Messi

Oddsivio estimated value

€11m

−31% this season

#1,419 of 11,790 players valued#44 of 721 in the Major League Soccer

€50m€100m€150m€200m3 Aug16 Nov€186m€11m

Questions fans ask

Have Haaland and Messi ever played against each other?

No. By 10 November 2026 they had never played in the same game and had never been team-mates: Haaland's clubs have been Bryne, Molde, Salzburg, Borussia Dortmund and Manchester City, Messi's Barcelona, Paris Saint-Germain and Inter Miami. The nearest they came was the 2026 World Cup, where England knocked Norway out in the quarter-finals and then lost to Argentina in the semi-finals. Off the pitch, both were at the 2023 Ballon d'Or ceremony in Paris, and FIFA's fan-voted Dream Team of the 2026 World Cup put them in the same forward line, with Kylian Mbappé.

How did Haaland's and Messi's 2022–23 seasons compare?

Haaland scored 52 goals in 53 games for City: 36 in the Premier League, a record for one season, and 12 in the Champions League, the most by anyone in that season's competition, five of them in one game against RB Leipzig. With four for Norway his total was 56, and City won the Premier League, the FA Cup and the Champions League. Messi scored 21 goals and set up 20 for Paris Saint-Germain, who won Ligue 1 with him making 16 assists, the most in the league. At the World Cup he scored seven goals and set up three in seven games, and became the first player to win its Golden Ball twice. Two other awards for that year went Haaland's way: he won the IFFHS's world player award for 2023, with Messi third, and the Globe Soccer award for the year's best men's player.

How do Haaland's numbers compare with Messi's at the same age?

It depends on what is counted. On Haaland's 26th birthday, 21 July 2026, Planet Football counted 359 goals in 435 games for club and country for him, against 348 in 461 for Messi at the same age, but 74 assists to Messi's 139. Haaland reached 200 career goals at 22 years and 261 days, Messi at 24 years and 54 days, by ESPN's count, and Haaland needed 49 Champions League games for his first 50 goals in the competition, the fewest of anyone, where Messi needed 66. Counting club goals alone, Messi got to 300 sooner, in 365 games to Haaland's 384, by Planet Football's figures of September 2026. Both have scored five goals in one Champions League game: Messi was the first to do it, against Bayer Leverkusen in March 2012, and Haaland did it against RB Leipzig in March 2023. Messi's Champions League career, which ended at PSG in 2023, brought 129 goals in 163 games; Haaland's 62nd goal in the competition came in his 61st game, on 4 November 2026.

What have Messi and Haaland said about each other?

Messi named Haaland in his acceptance speech for the 2023 Ballon d'Or, saying in Spanish that Haaland had won everything and that he had no doubt Haaland and Mbappé would win the award in the future. Haaland, asked in March 2024 about losing awards to Messi, said that Messi "won the World Cup, so I don't know what to say", and called him "the best that's ever played, I think". In November 2025, after Guardiola said Haaland's numbers put him at the level of Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo, Haaland's answer was "No, not at all! No one can get close to them two." In June 2026, hours after his own first World Cup goals, he greeted Messi's hat-trick against Algeria on Snapchat with "Messi is a madman".

What have Haaland and Messi won?

Messi's count is 48 team trophies by MLS's tally after Inter Miami won the Campeones Cup on 16 September 2026, from ten Spanish league titles and four Champions Leagues with Barcelona to the 2022 World Cup, the Copas América of 2021 and 2024 and the 2025 MLS Cup; he also has eight Ballon d'Ors and six European Golden Shoes, and in 2026 he became the first player to win MLS's Golden Boot two years running. Haaland won the Austrian league and cup with Salzburg in 2019 and the German Cup with Dortmund in 2021, and with City the treble of 2023, a second Premier League title in 2024, the UEFA Super Cup, the Community Shield, and the FA Cup and League Cup in 2026; Norway have won nothing with him. He has one European Golden Shoe, from 2022–23, and three Premier League Golden Boots, and his best Ballon d'Or finish is second, in 2023. At the 2026 Ballon d'Or, which Harry Kane won, Messi was fifth with 612 points and Haaland eighth with 378. Inter Miami were due to start the MLS play-offs against Columbus Crew on 21 November 2026, with MLS Cup scheduled for 18 December.

Who is better, Haaland or Messi?

Our written sections take no side; the verdict near the top comes from the numbers in the window you pick, and on 10 November 2026 it named no leader on goals in either full window. They are different kinds of forward: Haaland, 1.95 m tall, is a centre-forward whose game is built around finishing, while Messi, at 1.70 m, does much of his work before the final shot, as the card's rows for chances created and take-ons show. Both are left-footed. Messi is the older by 13 years: he was born in Rosario on 24 June 1987, and Haaland in Leeds on 21 July 2000.

We use cookies to measure how the site is used so we can improve it. Change your choice anytime via “Manage cookies” in the footer. See our Privacy Policy.