Robert Lewandowski vs Lionel Messi
Born little more than a year apart, they finished first and second for the 2021 Ballon d'Or, a year after the one that was never awarded, and have since met at a World Cup and, with both in MLS, in Chicago.
By the Oddsivio teamLast reviewed Stats updated

Last season · club and country together · official matches

Who does what?
Lionel Messi had the stronger recorded output last season: ahead on goals, chances created, assists and pass completion and behind on nothing.
Worth knowing: Robert Lewandowski had 3,067 minutes last season, Lionel Messi 3,981.
What separates them
4 of 4 pass both our tests: a big enough gap, and sure enough to hold.
- Lewandowski
- Messi
- Typical forwards
- Goals per 90Messi led0.6723 goals1.0245 goals
About 10 more goals over 30 full matches for Messi than Lewandowski.
Held up next season: about 8 in 10
- Chances created per 90Messi led0.931 chances3.2140 chances
About 3.5 times as many chances created: about 68 more over 30 full matches.
Held up next season: about 9 in 10
- Assists per 90Messi led0.155 assists0.4118 assists
About 8 more assists over 30 full matches for Messi than Lewandowski.
Held up next season: about 8 in 10
- Pass completion share of passes completedMessi led78%50%100%82%
Pass completion depends a lot on role and team.
Held up next season: about 8 in 10
Per 90 = per 90 minutes played, so different minutes compare fairly.
Does it hold up?
Without penalties
Lionel Messi still led (0.99 vs 0.65 per 90; 44 goals to 22).
How they play · volume, not a lead
Lionel Messi tried far more take-ons (5.9 vs 1.0 per 90) and shot more (3.5 vs 2.5 per 90) last season.
Why this comparison
France Football cancelled the 2020 Ballon d'Or on 20 July 2020, saying the pandemic had left too few games to compare players fairly. A month later Bayern completed the treble, with Lewandowski top scorer in the Bundesliga, the German Cup and the Champions League. The 2021 award, the last to cover a calendar year, was close: Lewandowski scored 41 Bundesliga goals in 2020–21, one more than Gerd Müller's record, and 69 for club and country in 2021 by UEFA's count, to Messi's 43; Messi won the Spanish scoring title, the Copa del Rey and, with Argentina, the 2021 Copa América. In Paris on 29 November 2021 Messi won with 613 points to Lewandowski's 580, after Lewandowski had been handed a new Striker of the Year award on the same stage.
Messi used his speech to say it was an honour to compete with Lewandowski, that everyone agreed Lewandowski had been the 2020 winner, and that France Football should give him that award. It never has. About a week later Lewandowski told the Polish channel Kanał Sportowy he hoped the words had been sincere and "not just empty words"; a statement reported by kicker then said he had been misread and the speech had touched him deeply. Messi later said they had agreed it was a misunderstanding.
Every number · last season
| Stat | ||
|---|---|---|
3,067 | Minutes | 3,981 |
53 | Matches | 46 |
70.62Important · 24 club games · as of 2026-11-22 | Current squad importance | 87.5Star · 40 club games · as of 2026-11-22 |
0.6723 in total | goals per 90 | 1.0245 in total |
0.155 in total | assists per 90 | 0.4118 in total |
0.931 in total | chances created per 90 | 3.2140 in total |
2.584 in total | shots per 90 | 3.5154 in total |
1.033 in total | take-ons tried per 90 | 5.9263 in total |
0.413 in total | tackles per 90 | 0.733 in total |
0.27 in total | interceptions per 90 | 0.16 in total |
4.1141 in total | duels won per 90 | 5.7254 in total |
78% | pass completion | 82% |
Goals and assists are counted from match events; the other counts come from the provider's detailed match stats. Squad importance describes the current club role over its recent club-game window; it is independent of the comparison window.
Have they played each other?
Five times as opponents, and our list below has three of them: our records do not include Barcelona's 2014–15 season, so the Champions League semi-final of May 2015 is missing. Barcelona won the first leg 3–0 at the Camp Nou on 6 May, with two goals from Messi, against a Lewandowski playing in a mask after breaking his jaw and nose a week earlier; in Munich six days later he scored Bayern's equaliser in a 3–2 win that was not enough to stop Barcelona going through. Bayern beat Barcelona 8–2 in a one-off quarter-final in Lisbon on 14 August 2020, with Lewandowski among the scorers. At the 2022 World Cup Argentina beat Poland 2–0 in Doha, after Wojciech Szczęsny had saved a Messi penalty, and both teams went through; in stoppage time Lewandowski fouled Messi and offered his hand, and Messi ignored it. Lewandowski's first MLS game, away to Inter Miami on 22 July 2026, came without Messi, who was rested after the World Cup final. Their first meeting in MLS was Chicago Fire 1–1 Inter Miami at Soldier Field on the evening of 9 September 2026, the early hours of 10 September in Europe, which is the date on our list: in front of a club-record crowd of 63,094 Lewandowski scored, Messi set up the equaliser from a corner, and late on Lewandowski and Messi's team-mate Rodrigo De Paul had to be pulled apart. The two clubs could meet again only in the Eastern Conference final of the 2026 play-offs, on 11 or 12 December 2026, and are scheduled to play at Soldier Field on 20 March 2027. They have never been team-mates.
Looking up their matches…
What the numbers don't show
The card's last season is a different year for each of them. For Lewandowski it is Barcelona's 2025–26 season, his last there, with Poland's games in it: 53 games but only 3,067 minutes, an average of 58 a game. For Messi it is Inter Miami's 2025 season, from February to MLS Cup in December, with Argentina's competitive games up to the 2026 World Cup final: 46 games and 3,981 minutes. One was played mostly in La Liga and the other mostly in MLS, and the card does not adjust for the strength of a league. Its 2026 window is the first in which they play in the same league: Lewandowski's Chicago Fire games since July and Messi's Inter Miami games since February.
They do different jobs, and the card shows it. Over its two years to 12 November 2026 Messi created more than three times as many chances per 90 minutes as Lewandowski and tried more than four times as many take-ons. Ten of Lewandowski's 60 goals in that window were penalties and two of Messi's 73, which the row without penalties sets aside. Over their careers Transfermarkt counts 93 penalties scored from 105 for Lewandowski and 117 from 152 for Messi.
Messi's figures on the card are a floor. Our records leave out some of Inter Miami's competitions, among them the Concacaf Champions Cup, in which he scored his 900th career goal in March 2026, and our feed credits only the last pass before a goal, where MLS also counts the pass before it when it leads straight to a goal. The card gives him 14 assists in his 2026 games; MLS counts 17 in the regular season alone.
Estimated value
Lionel Messi's Oddsivio estimated value is higher: €11m (#1,419 of 11,790 players valued) to Robert Lewandowski's €1.6m (#7,149 of 11,790 players valued). Lewandowski's estimate dipped 13% this season; Messi's estimate dipped 31% this season.Oddsivio estimated value — a model estimate from recent performance data, not betting advice.
Robert Lewandowski
Oddsivio estimated value
€1.6m
−13% this season
#7,149 of 11,790 players valued#543 of 721 in the Major League Soccer
Lionel Messi
Oddsivio estimated value
€11m
−31% this season
#1,419 of 11,790 players valued#44 of 721 in the Major League Soccer
Questions fans ask
Have Lewandowski and Messi ever been team-mates?
No. Messi left Barcelona in August 2021, when the club said economic and structural obstacles stopped it completing the new contract it had agreed with him, and joined Paris Saint-Germain; Lewandowski arrived from Bayern Munich on 19 July 2022 and wore the No 9 shirt for four seasons. In November 2022 he told Marca that for a striker it would be "a dream to play with Lionel Messi", and in April 2023, with Messi's contract in Paris running out, he said he hoped they could play together at Barcelona the next season; that June Messi chose Inter Miami instead. Lewandowski played his last game for Barcelona in May 2026, with 120 goals in 193 games and seven trophies, and on 29 June 2026 he signed for Chicago Fire, who play in the same MLS conference as Inter Miami.
How did Lewandowski's and Messi's 2021 stats compare?
In the calendar year the 2021 Ballon d'Or covered, UEFA counted 69 goals in 59 games for Lewandowski, the most in Europe, and 43 in 60 for Messi. Lewandowski's 41 Bundesliga goals in 2020–21 came in 29 games, the last of them in the final minutes of the season against Augsburg on 22 May 2021, and won him the European Golden Shoe, with Messi second on 30. Messi won the Spanish scoring title for the eighth time, scored twice in Barcelona's 4–0 Copa del Rey final win over Athletic Club, and at the Copa América was joint top scorer with four goals, level with Luis Díaz, and gave the most assists, five, as Argentina beat Brazil 1–0 in the final. FIFA's The Best went to Lewandowski in both years: in December 2020 with 52 points, Messi third on 35, and in January 2022, for 2021, by 48 points to Messi's 44.
What happened between Lewandowski and Messi?
It began with Messi's 2021 Ballon d'Or speech and the FIFA votes that followed. FIFA publishes every national-team captain's ballot: for The Best of 2021 Messi, as Argentina's captain, voted for Neymar, Kylian Mbappé and Karim Benzema and left Lewandowski out, while Lewandowski put Messi second. After winning in January 2022 Lewandowski said Messi would have to be asked why he had not voted for him. In May 2022 Messi told TyC Sports he did not share what Lewandowski had said and was not interested. At the 2022 World Cup Messi ignored Lewandowski's hand after a late foul; Lewandowski called it a fun little duel and said everything was fine, and Messi said that what happens on the pitch stays there. A year later, in a Star+ series, Messi said Lewandowski's reaction to his Ballon d'Or speech had annoyed him, because he had meant what he said, that he had taken him on again in Doha because it was him, and that when they later talked they agreed it had been a misunderstanding. Lewandowski voted Messi first for The Best of 2022, and in Chicago in September 2026 they greeted each other on the pitch.
How do Lewandowski's and Messi's scoring records compare?
In the Champions League Messi scored 129 goals in 163 games, second only to Cristiano Ronaldo, and Lewandowski 109, the third-highest total, against a record 41 different opponents; his four goals for Borussia Dortmund against Real Madrid in 2013 are still the only four-goal game in a Champions League semi-final. Messi has eight Champions League hat-tricks, level with Ronaldo's record, to Lewandowski's six. Messi's 474 goals are the Spanish league's record; Lewandowski's 312 in the Bundesliga are second to Gerd Müller's 365. Messi holds the record for goals in a calendar year, 91 in 2012, and Lewandowski four Guinness World Records from one night in September 2015, when he came on at half-time against Wolfsburg and scored five goals in 8 minutes 59 seconds. For their countries, Messi finished with 126 goals in 208 games for Argentina, and Lewandowski had 92 in 170 for Poland after a hat-trick against Romania on 2 October 2026; both are national records.
What have Lewandowski and Messi won?
By MLS's counts Messi has 48 team trophies, the 48th the Campeones Cup with Inter Miami on 16 September 2026, and Lewandowski 33. Messi's include ten Spanish league titles and four Champions Leagues with Barcelona, the 2022 World Cup, two Copas América and the 2025 MLS Cup; he has eight Ballon d'Ors and a record six European Golden Shoes, and in 2026 he became the first player to win MLS's Golden Boot in consecutive seasons. Lewandowski has won ten Bundesliga titles, two with Dortmund and eight with Bayern, the 2020 Champions League and three Spanish league titles with Barcelona. His individual awards include FIFA's The Best for 2020 and 2021, the European Golden Shoe for 2020–21 and 2021–22, France Football's striker award in its first two years, seven Bundesliga scoring titles and the Spanish one for 2022–23; he has won no trophy with Poland, and his best Ballon d'Or finish is second, in 2021. Both clubs reached the 2026 MLS play-offs, Inter Miami as second in the Eastern Conference and Chicago Fire as fourth, their highest finish since 2017; Inter Miami are due to start against Columbus Crew on 21 November 2026 and Chicago Fire against Charlotte FC a day later, with MLS Cup on 18 December 2026.
Who is better, Lewandowski or Messi?
The card near the top gives the numbers' answer for the window you choose, and these written sections take no side. On 12 November 2026 it found their goals per 90 minutes too close to call in the 2026 window, the first with both in MLS, and put Messi ahead on goals over the last full season and over two years. They are different kinds of forward: Lewandowski, about 1.85 m tall and right-footed, is a centre-forward, and Messi, 1.70 m and left-footed, creates far more for others and takes on far more defenders, as the card's rows for chances created and take-ons show. Messi is the older by a little over a year: he was born in Rosario on 24 June 1987, and Lewandowski in Warsaw on 21 August 1988.

